Obama's reversal on the ban was a year long review on whether it should be unbanned or not.
Mattis delayed the review last month on the final day and now Trump has decided the answer should be no. So there never has been an open transgender in the military. There very well could be in secret, obviously. But the notion that people will now be kicked out or that people will lose their VA benefits is false. Just fyi. Edit: transgender in the title, not transexual. Edit 2: Is there a reason you're all freaking out? Even CNN says what I said here: http://www.cnn.com/2017/07/26/politics/trump-military-transgender/index.html Maybe you should all due your homework before flipping out. |
Gradieus posted...
Mattis delayed the review last month on the final day But Clintonites will still keep sucking up to Mattis. |
Wrong. Chelsea Manning.
Play Nier: Automata
4 8 15 16 23 42 |
thats bs. sergeant shane ortega is openly trans and is actively serving in the army
WWE Champ The Maharaja Jinder Mahal
YOU CAN'T HINDER THE JINDER!!!!! |
What part of "cannot serve in any capacity" is vague or would allow people serving in secret to continue or receive an honorable discharge?
Posted with GameRaven 3.2.1
|
cannonball_java posted...
Wrong. Chelsea Manning. Alternative facts Her name was Bradley Manning and as such was not open trans /s |
Conservatives like Gradieus like to pretend there's no trans people with officer commissions or commands.
To him, everyone trans is expendable and at the lowest enlistment pay grades.
Posted with GameRaven 3.2.1
|
omega bahumat posted...
cannonball_java posted...Wrong. Chelsea Manning. At the time, yes. She was never actually discharged however and is (or I suppose was now) returning to active duty. http://time.com/4778809/chelsea-manning-active-duty-army-prison-release/ Edit: I'm a dumbass and didn't read the /s
Play Nier: Automata
4 8 15 16 23 42 |
try doing some goddamn research before talking out your ass again gradieus
WWE Champ The Maharaja Jinder Mahal
YOU CAN'T HINDER THE JINDER!!!!! |
If the only reason you couldn't be GI Jane while you were GI Joe busting *** in Iraq was because you would get booted from the armed forces by folks who think you're mentally unwell or a deviant, that isn't something to use as a "Checkmate libs"
It shows the same BS used to stop black soldiers, female soldiers or gay soldiers is now being used against trans soldiers. |
lol, Gradieus topic™
"That was pretty interesting, but dropping a warship on me is cheating ... take it back!"
|
Bluebomber182 posted...
try doing some goddamn research before talking out your ass again gradieus Stating facts is talking out of my ass? lol K. |
Starks posted...
What part of "cannot serve in any capacity" is vague or would allow people serving in secret to continue or receive an honorable discharge? They'd probably be administratively separated with an "Honorable" characterization of service if this holds.
[Youtube Channel: https://www.youtube.com/user/AlesandrosX?feature=mhee]
Non mihi, non tibi, sed nobis. |
Not a big fan of this ban, but people always tend to overreact to things. They pretend deporting illegal immigrants means deporting all immigrants and banning people from 6 countries means banning all Muslims in the world.
Start me, bench Forte
|
Gradieus needs to address my earlier point.
Posted with GameRaven 3.2.1
|
alternative facts maybe. you gonna overlook shane ortega?
WWE Champ The Maharaja Jinder Mahal
YOU CAN'T HINDER THE JINDER!!!!! |
cannonball_java posted...
Wrong. Chelsea Manning. Only after sentencing it was revealed. Bluebomber182 posted... thats bs. sergeant shane ortega is openly trans and is actively serving in the army Ortega is currently retired and at the time was tested by doctors and psychologists and was deemed to be 100% male. So he wouldn't lose any VA benefits either. There is no documented case of anyone who will be thrown out of the military and VA benefits cut over this. |
Starks posted...
Gradieus needs to address my earlier point. Your point was stupid. I view all Americans equal and treat all Americans equal. How the military decides what's in their best interest to protect Americans is their own perogative. This topic is about facts, not about what you think I think. |
I wonder how much better or worse this board would be if posters could only make one topic per...erm, topic.
All animals can scream.
|
So if we had a trans 1-star general, they're gone?
Gradieus, show some courage for your ideas or back off.
Posted with GameRaven 3.2.1
|
The military is an extension of the government and our society at large. Trans Americans have to pay taxes. Their taxes go to funding the military, just like ours. If they are barred from service outright, regardless of work ethic, individual competence, etc., I damn sure hope they get a big, fat gift back from Uncle Sam come tax season.
|
Starks posted...
So if we had a trans 1-star general, they're gone? The way these policies should work is that current recruits receive immunity but no new ones are accepted. |
Starks posted...
So if we had a trans 1-star general, they're gone? Can you name them? No? Then what's the problem? |
I can't name any. Maybe there's one still the closet or living a double-life like Manning did. Would you try to uncover and remove such a general?
Come on, take this to the logical conclusion. We're going to lose good people through protest or resignation even if grandfather clauses protect.
Posted with GameRaven 3.2.1
|
Starks posted...
I can't name any. Maybe there's one still the closet or living a double-life like Manning did. Would you try to uncover and remove such a general? I can't understand your train of thought, no. If they're unknown yesterday why would they reveal themselves now that the ban hasn't been lifted? In the military you learn to stfu and do your job. That's why you can't name anyone. Edit: no one is going to try and seek them out. This isn't a witch hunt. I don't even know how you would even go about "seeking them out" anyway. And I don't want to know. Nothing changed from yesterday. |
Gradieus posted...
So there never has been an open transgender in the military. So what branch were you in and when? Because approximately 1 year ago in the navy, I knew 2 that were openly trans. |
reallydontknow posted...
Gradieus posted...So there never has been an open transgender in the military. Who? |
What are you going to report them?
Posted with GameRaven 3.2.1
|
"Trump will be far better for LGBT than Hillary. Believe me."
|
Bluebomber182 posted...
thats bs. sergeant shane ortega is openly trans and is actively serving in the army
3 things 1. i am female 2. i havea msucle probelm its hard for me to typ well 3.*does her janpuu dance*
|
A SEAL Team 6 vet just came out as trans.
Posted with GameRaven 3.2.1
|
AceMos posted...
Bluebomber182 posted...thats bs. sergeant shane ortega is openly trans and is actively serving in the army Already covered in post 19. |
Gradieus posted...
reallydontknow posted...Gradieus posted...So there never has been an open transgender in the military. 2 great sailors. That's who they were. Once again, what branch were you in and when? Since your statement is so definitive, you must have served. |
reallydontknow posted...
Gradieus posted...reallydontknow posted...Gradieus posted...So there never has been an open transgender in the military. If you can't even name them then they were never openly transgendered in the military. So what are you whining about? |
Gradieus posted...
reallydontknow posted...Gradieus posted...reallydontknow posted...Gradieus posted...So there never has been an open transgender in the military. Sounds like you want to know their names so you can harass them like the alt-righter you are.
Bell Maiden is my waifu.
|
Gradieus posted...
reallydontknow posted...Gradieus posted...reallydontknow posted...Gradieus posted...So there never has been an open transgender in the military. Ok. Sure I can't name them. Not sure how I am whining, just asking about your service, since you know for a fact about transgender serving in the military. Care to answer? |
reallydontknow posted...
Gradieus posted...reallydontknow posted...Gradieus posted...reallydontknow posted...Gradieus posted...So there never has been an open transgender in the military. No one can name a single open transgender person. Case closed. |
And that's your threshold for good policy? "Nobody I know is screwed"
This space for rent
|
According to the military there are 250 active duty troops wanting surgery (and more that either don't or aren't out about it). Each one deserves respect, yet Trump and his troll army just decided to bash their service and pretend they're all dangers to America who can't serve their country. Nice.
|
Gradieus posted...
reallydontknow posted...Gradieus posted...reallydontknow posted...Gradieus posted...reallydontknow posted...Gradieus posted...So there never has been an open transgender in the military. You have no military experience to make that claim. Case closed. |
reallydontknow posted...
You have no military experience to make that claim. Case closed. Is this how the Left thinks? I can't say it's raining outside because I'm not a meteorologist! Lmao. Learn what facts are. |
Gradieus posted...
reallydontknow posted...You have no military experience to make that claim. Case closed. Facts like Gradieus is a pedo or Gradieus likes posting other people's financial reports as his own. Which fact is true?
Bell Maiden is my waifu.
|
I'll get shit on for this but here we go. There's absolutely no reason whatsoever that any member of society should be labelled as "transgender".
A person born a male that got surgery and medications and whatever else to become a woman is a woman. A trans woman, at best, is someone pre-op that still has the physical traits of a male. If anyone is in that transformative stage, then they shouldn't be in the army. Same with female to male transgender. Get what you need done first, then try again as your actual new gender. Not a fucking transgender, because that's meaningless and only shows you can't make up your mind. No one should have to deal with your flip flopping bullshit. If you became transgender just to make a point or to gain popularity, then you're a fucking idiot that should be exiled from society. |
Gradieus posted...
reallydontknow posted...You have no military experience to make that claim. Case closed. Facts are there are at least 3000 transgender people in the military. But hey, you know those pesky facts that you're ignoring. |
reallydontknow posted...
Gradieus posted...reallydontknow posted...You have no military experience to make that claim. Case closed. Estimated because no one is outright saying they are in the open. It's called statistics. |
Ultima, do you even know what non-binary is? They don't want to choose a gender or never had one.
Posted with GameRaven 3.2.1
|
Starks posted...
Ultima, do you even know what non-binary is? They don't want to choose a gender or never had one. Which means they're problematic. Your point? |
- Boards
- Politics
- Reminder: No transexual ever openly worked for the US military
Ultimaspirit posted...Starks posted...
Ultima, do you even know what non-binary is? They don't want to choose a gender or never had one.
Which means they're problematic. Your point?
How?"Hey bridesmaid, love the beard! Give's me something to hang onto!!"- Lord Flasheartmad_hax_man posted...Ultimaspirit posted...
Starks posted...
Ultima, do you even know what non-binary is? They don't want to choose a gender or never had one.
Which means they're problematic. Your point?
How?
If you don't fit in to a designated role in society then no one should be put in to the position of trusting their life to someone that can't make up their own mind about who they are. There's tons of other career paths out there that don't require you to be in the middle of a literal war zone.Ultimaspirit posted...mad_hax_man posted...
Ultimaspirit posted...
Starks posted...
Ultima, do you even know what non-binary is? They don't want to choose a gender or never had one.
Which means they're problematic. Your point?
How?
If you don't fit in to a designated role in society then no one should be put in to the position of trusting their life to someone that can't make up their own mind about who they are. There's tons of other career paths out there that don't require you to be in the middle of a literal war zone.
I don't know where to start with this.
-Transgender people on the whole aren't people that "haven't made up their mind" Some of them are, but mostly its people who have made up their mind and have come to a conclusion that pisses off a lot of bigots.
-And if a society isn't changing its understandings to include a naturally occurring, scientifically observable biological phenomena, then that's on said societies head."Hey bridesmaid, love the beard! Give's me something to hang onto!!"- Lord FlasheartYahaha! You found me!Bluebomber182 posted...try doing some goddamn research before talking out your ass again gradieus
He should try doing a little research before impersonating Reddit users too.Make America Great(ish) Again Impeach Donald "Snowflake" TrumpGradieus posted...reallydontknow posted...
You have no military experience to make that claim. Case closed.
Is this how the Left thinks? I can't say it's raining outside because I'm not a meteorologist!
Lmao. Learn what facts are.
And you used the logic of "unless you give me names of specific individuals, they do not exist". It's not your meteorologist thing, but it's close. I'm surprised you didn't ask for the names of the 15,000 estimated to be currently serving. I'm sure you'd read all the thousands of names, if it existed. But why name and shame these people? Are you going to go verify their identities after?
Gradieus posted...reallydontknow posted...
Gradieus posted...
reallydontknow posted...
You have no military experience to make that claim. Case closed.
Is this how the Left thinks? I can't say it's raining outside because I'm not a meteorologist!
Lmao. Learn what facts are.
Facts are there are at least 3000 transgender people in the military. But hey, you know those pesky facts that you're ignoring.
Estimated because no one is outright saying they are in the open. It's called statistics.
I'm pretty sure an estimation of 3,000 wouldn't also allow for there to be 0. That's one hell of a margin of error."Every single Jedi, including your friend Obi-Wan, is now an enemy of the Republic. Do what must be done. Do not hesitate. Show no mercy."cannonball_java posted...Wrong. Chelsea Manning.
TundraKing87 posted...The military is an extension of the government and our society at large. Trans Americans have to pay taxes. Their taxes go to funding the military, just like ours. If they are barred from service outright, regardless of work ethic, individual competence, etc., I damn sure hope they get a big, fat gift back from Uncle Sam come tax season.
Word. I would voluntarily put myself on a "never able to enlist" list if it meant all my taxes going to the military were refunded to me.RogueJedi86 posted...And you used the logic of "unless you give me names of specific individuals, they do not exist".
Pointing out the obvious that they're not open about it because it's always been bannable. If one can't name their names then they're not open about it. That's it, that's my point. Of course there's transgenders in the military, I never said there wasn't. But there's a difference whether you're open about it or not because it's bannable.Gradieus posted...RogueJedi86 posted...
And you used the logic of "unless you give me names of specific individuals, they do not exist".
Pointing out the obvious that they're not open about it because it's always been bannable. If one can't name their names then they're not open about it. That's it, that's my point. Of course there's transgenders in the military, I never said there wasn't. But there's a difference whether you're open about it or not because it's bannable.
That's because I chose not to name them.
Bannable? Most seniors don't care who or what you are or do if you do your job and keep your nose clean. One sailor I knew use to travel on the weekend to do international pole dancing competitions.( but according to you it didn't happen) , our skipper knew about it.
But let's play your logic.Tell me the numbers on your bank account.
If you can't, you don't have one.
But if names are so important.
"Jim" and "Pickle"First of all, that doesn't have any bearing on whether or not they should.
Second, it's not true. See Logan Island and Jacob Eleazer."The only things I can trust right now are myself and this big gun." - Eric from Zero Time Dilemma
http://steamcommunity.com/id/Garioshi/wishlistreallydontknow posted...Gradieus posted...
RogueJedi86 posted...
And you used the logic of "unless you give me names of specific individuals, they do not exist".
Pointing out the obvious that they're not open about it because it's always been bannable. If one can't name their names then they're not open about it. That's it, that's my point. Of course there's transgenders in the military, I never said there wasn't. But there's a difference whether you're open about it or not because it's bannable.
That's because I chose not to name them.
Bannable? Most seniors don't care who or what you are or do if you do your job and keep your nose clean. One sailor I knew use to travel on the weekend to do international pole dancing competitions.( but according to you it didn't happen) , our skipper knew about it.
But let's play your logic.Tell me the numbers on your bank account.
If you can't, you don't have one.
But if names are so important.
"Jim" and "Pickle"
"Seniors don't care!"
Okay name their names.
"Not going to name names!"
Okkkay. Clearly you don't want to name them for fear they'll get kicked out of the military. So if you fear that then maybe someone above them does care.Gradieus posted...reallydontknow posted...
Gradieus posted...
RogueJedi86 posted...
And you used the logic of "unless you give me names of specific individuals, they do not exist".
Pointing out the obvious that they're not open about it because it's always been bannable. If one can't name their names then they're not open about it. That's it, that's my point. Of course there's transgenders in the military, I never said there wasn't. But there's a difference whether you're open about it or not because it's bannable.
That's because I chose not to name them.
Bannable? Most seniors don't care who or what you are or do if you do your job and keep your nose clean. One sailor I knew use to travel on the weekend to do international pole dancing competitions.( but according to you it didn't happen) , our skipper knew about it.
But let's play your logic.Tell me the numbers on your bank account.
If you can't, you don't have one.
But if names are so important.
"Jim" and "Pickle"
"Seniors don't care!"
Okay name their names.
"Not going to name names!"
Okkkay. Clearly you don't want to name them for fear they'll get kicked out of the military. So if you fear that then maybe someone above them does care.
People have the right to privacy and you're seriously trying to bait people into posting personal information????????feudel posted...Why the **** do you care. Stop being a transphobic yokel. Then again you'll just mark anyone who disagrees with you and then complain your freedom of speech is being squelched.
I dunno mate, everyone keeps telling me there's already open transgender people in the military, that the seniors don't care, that it's all normal.
And yet don't dare tell someone online the names of these people.
Maybe, just maybe, it's not as open as they want us to believe.reminder: no username named Gradieus ever openly made a non-troll topicfeudel posted...
People have the right to privacy and you're seriously trying to bait people into posting personal information
I asked who they were describing to see whether it's truly open or not. Obviously it isn't.
Excuse me for not just believing some stranger on the internet that "everyone's open about being transgender in the military".
How you don't see that I proved it's not open is beyond me.Well for what it's worth, the NYT has someone on record:Lt. Commander Blake Dremann, a Navy supply corps officer who is transgender, said he found out his job was in danger when he turned on CNN on Wednesday morning. Commander Dremann came out as transgender to his commanders in 2015, and said they had been supportive of him.
He refused to criticize Mr. Trump — “we don’t criticize our commander in chief,” he said — but said the policy shift “is singling out a specific population in the military, who had been assured we were doing everything appropriate to continue our honorable service.”
He added: “And I will continue to do so, until the military tells me to hang up my boots.”Gradieus posted...feudel posted...
Why the **** do you care. Stop being a transphobic yokel. Then again you'll just mark anyone who disagrees with you and then complain your freedom of speech is being squelched.
I dunno mate, everyone keeps telling me there's already open transgender people in the military, that the seniors don't care, that it's all normal.
And yet don't dare tell someone online the names of these people.
Maybe, just maybe, it's not as open as they want us to believe.
Why does it matter to you? do transgendered people upset you? Do you get "anxious"? Do you get mad? Are you just secretly at odds with your own gender identity you lash out at others?
Please tell us why this bothers you so much.????????TimeForAction posted...Well for what it's worth, the NYT has someone on record:
Lt. Commander Blake Dremann, a Navy supply corps officer who is transgender, said he found out his job was in danger when he turned on CNN on Wednesday morning. Commander Dremann came out as transgender to his commanders in 2015, and said they had been supportive of him.
He refused to criticize Mr. Trump — “we don’t criticize our commander in chief,” he said — but said the policy shift “is singling out a specific population in the military, who had been assured we were doing everything appropriate to continue our honorable service.”
He added: “And I will continue to do so, until the military tells me to hang up my boots.”
Great, but he's now going to be one of the first ones gone.feudel posted...Gradieus posted...
feudel posted...
Why the **** do you care. Stop being a transphobic yokel. Then again you'll just mark anyone who disagrees with you and then complain your freedom of speech is being squelched.
I dunno mate, everyone keeps telling me there's already open transgender people in the military, that the seniors don't care, that it's all normal.
And yet don't dare tell someone online the names of these people.
Maybe, just maybe, it's not as open as they want us to believe.
Why does it matter to you? do transgendered people upset you? Do you get "anxious"? Do you get mad? Are you just secretly at odds with your own gender identity you lash out at others?
Please tell us why this bothers you so much.
Only one freaking out here is you. President has spoken.Gradieus posted...TimeForAction posted...
Well for what it's worth, the NYT has someone on record:
Lt. Commander Blake Dremann, a Navy supply corps officer who is transgender, said he found out his job was in danger when he turned on CNN on Wednesday morning. Commander Dremann came out as transgender to his commanders in 2015, and said they had been supportive of him.
He refused to criticize Mr. Trump — “we don’t criticize our commander in chief,” he said — but said the policy shift “is singling out a specific population in the military, who had been assured we were doing everything appropriate to continue our honorable service.”
He added: “And I will continue to do so, until the military tells me to hang up my boots.”
Great, but he's now going to be one of the first ones gone.
Great. So you're wrong. There is an open trans in the military. Lol.Gradieus posted...feudel posted...
Gradieus posted...
feudel posted...
Why the **** do you care. Stop being a transphobic yokel. Then again you'll just mark anyone who disagrees with you and then complain your freedom of speech is being squelched.
I dunno mate, everyone keeps telling me there's already open transgender people in the military, that the seniors don't care, that it's all normal.
And yet don't dare tell someone online the names of these people.
Maybe, just maybe, it's not as open as they want us to believe.
Why does it matter to you? do transgendered people upset you? Do you get "anxious"? Do you get mad? Are you just secretly at odds with your own gender identity you lash out at others?
Please tell us why this bothers you so much.
Only one freaking out here is you. President has spoken.
And he got checked by the joint chiefs. Chairman said ignore twitterfingers.Gradieus posted...feudel posted...
Gradieus posted...
feudel posted...
Why the **** do you care. Stop being a transphobic yokel. Then again you'll just mark anyone who disagrees with you and then complain your freedom of speech is being squelched.
I dunno mate, everyone keeps telling me there's already open transgender people in the military, that the seniors don't care, that it's all normal.
And yet don't dare tell someone online the names of these people.
Maybe, just maybe, it's not as open as they want us to believe.
Why does it matter to you? do transgendered people upset you? Do you get "anxious"? Do you get mad? Are you just secretly at odds with your own gender identity you lash out at others?
Please tell us why this bothers you so much.
Only one freaking out here is you. President has spoken.
Your the one asking for peoples names. i'm simply asking what is your issue with the transgendered. Don't try to ignore me????????Why would anybody want to be transgender in the military. You're just be bullied to oblivion. You might as well go jump of a 3 story building if an openly trans person is going to join the militaryGarioshi posted...First of all, that doesn't have any bearing on whether or not they should.
Second, it's not true. See Logan Island and Jacob Eleazer."The only things I can trust right now are myself and this big gun." - Eric from Zero Time Dilemma
http://steamcommunity.com/id/Garioshi/wishlist
No comments:
Post a Comment